Dutch Harbor X
For FSX Published by Aerosoft
Reviewed by Rob Scott
June 2010

Most people at some point during their FS careers will have made a flight in Alaska; its stunning beauty is second to none and is a bush flyers paradise. Whether you are flying in and out of the remote airstrips in a STOL aircraft, flying cargo from Anchorage in the heavies or taking passengers to a remote lakeside retreat for a weekend of fishing, you cannot escape the beauty of the landscape.

Dutch Harbor
One of the most challenging airports in Alaska, possibly the world, is the famous Dutch Harbour (PADU) airport on Unalaska Island. In 2002 it was renamed Tom Madsen Airport in honour of a bush pilot who was killed in an accident that year, however, the FAA still refers to it as Unalaska Airport. The airport is surrounded by danger, starting with the runway which is only 3,900ft long, has very little runoff area (unless you count the sea) and is surrounded by high terrain. Getting the approach wrong here can spell big trouble. Combine that with the treacherous weather – 250 rainy days a year, constant fogs, heavy crosswinds and freezing temperatures – it’s easy to see why there are so many missed approaches and cancelled flights here. Aircraft can expect to fly for an extra hour to get to an alternate airport if they cannot land at Dutch Harbour.

About the Product
Aerosoft and Thorsten Reichert have taken it upon themselves to recreate this challenging airport for FSX in high detail to make the challenge of landing here even more fun! The add-on can be purchased directly from the Aerosoft download shop for the very reasonable price of €17.95 and comes as a 260mb download (600mb installed). After downloading the installer from Aerosoft’s super fast servers it takes a matter of minutes to get the scenery installed using the quick installation/verification process.

Although this product is titled Dutch Harbour X, you get much more than just an airport:
  • Custom terrain, landclass and LOD11 mesh of the Aleutian Islands
  • Custom landclass, textures and seasons
  • Dutch Harbor scenery with port, town, landmarks and airport
  • Custom night effects
  • Runway lights (on request)
  • Additional airfields and villages:
    • Nikolski Airfield
    • Akutan Seaplane Base
    • Chernofski Seaplane Base
    • Fort Glenn Air Force Base (abandoned)
    • Driftwood Bay Air Force Station (abandoned)
  • Additional landmarks and WWII relicts
  • Volcano effects (see FAQ in manual about how to see them)
  • Tutorial mission and adjusted default missions
  • Free flights with typical weather conditions
  • Season selector tool
  • DX10 compatible
 
Courtesy of Aerosoft

Whilst there are extra airfields included, they are not anywhere near as detailed as Dutch Harbour itself, but they do make a nice place to start flights and are an improvement over the default offerings from Microsoft. You are also given a 14 page pdf manual that includes information about the add-on, best system settings, approach charts and notes about the changes made to your .cfg file to help prevent flatten issues with the water around the airport (FSGlobal users only). The manual also provides you with links to YouTube videos of some approaches into the airport.

Let's Go!
Of course, the thing you are going to want to do first is to jump into your favourite aircraft and fly the NDB approach in challenging weather. I urge you not to do that just yet as you will miss most of the scenery. Set your weather theme to clear skies with good visibility and jump into a helicopter and explore the scenery. The town and port around the airport have been recreated in fantastic detail with cranes, buildings, ships, containers and cars littering the area. One thing worth noting is that when I tried to explore the area on the ground in a car is that the car falls through the scenery soon after you leave the airport, but a helicopter is a good alternative. The scenery doesn’t just end once you leave the airport, take some time to explore it and enjoy what you have purchased. There are lots of detailed ships around the port area, but you will be unable to land your helicopter on them as, again, you will fall through the scenery (at least I did anyway!)

NOTAM
If you are expecting the same level of detail in the terrain that is included in some of Aerosoft’s other scenery products you may be left disappointed as it’s simply not there. This is no fault of Aerosoft’s because the usual high resolution images they work with just aren’t available for remote areas such as the Aleutian Islands. As usual Aerosoft have worked with what they have got and done an excellent job of it.

Once you are done exploring I would recommend giving one of the missions a go. Whilst there are 3 included, only 1 is new as the 2 default missions have been adapted for this new scenery. Have a go at Aerosoft’s own mission first as this will give you some information about the area and serves as a prequel to the 2 default missions: Aleutian Cargo & Dutch Harbour Approach. The new mission only takes around 15 minutes to complete and is well worth doing. (Tip, wait for a few seconds after you have landed for another challenge)

Weather
As mentioned earlier, the weather around Dutch Harbour is notoriously bad. I used 3 different weather programs (FSX Default, Active Sky and REX2) to generate the weather here and it ranged from as expected to clear and blue skies for the same time of day! Active Sky was by far the best at recreating the conditions I would have expected, but once I moved away from the immediate vicinity of the airport the weather became much clearer and easier to fly in. Again, this is no fault of Aerosoft’s, but the placing of the weather stations in FS and the weather program used. You can always create your own theme and tailor the weather conditions to suit your taste. It’s very satisfying to fly the NDB approach in crazy weather and have the runway pop into sight at the last minute; try the ‘Dutch Harbour Approach’ mission if you don’t believe me.

Summary
Dutch Harbour is one of those airports that you will probably only fly into if you like a challenge. If you want a nice easy ILS approach over flat terrain buy another product; the only landing guidance you get here is an NDB and the Mark 1 Eyeball. Aerosoft have managed to recreate one of the most challenging airports in the world in very accurate detail. Even though the usual high resolution images they work with are not available for this area, I don’t think there will be many complaints about how good the area looks. The main factor in the approach to the airport is the weather, and this will depend greatly upon your weather program, but there is nothing to stop you creating your own theme and having some fun.



Verdict

Aerosoft have gone above and beyond what the add-on title suggests and provided much more than just an airport; the extended scenery range, extra scenery at airports, volcano effects and missions all help to offset the fact that the usual high detail is not available. With everything combined this is a very attractive package and will be a firm favourite with bush flyers and those who love hard approaches.

When writing a review at Mutley's Hangar we like to give scoring based on how well the add-on meets what it sets out to do. Scoring will always begin at 10/10 with points deducted as necessary.

When taking everything into consideration I can only find 1 fault with this add-on, and that is the cars falling through the scenery and not being able to land the helicopters on the ships in the port. Only a minor niggle but I am please to give this add-on a Mutley’s Hangar score of 9/10



/Rob Scott


      
      System Requirements
  • Flight Simulator X (Acceleration or FSX SP2 required)
  • Windows XP / Vista / Windows7 with the latest Service Packs
  • Pentium 2 GHz (Duo2Core Intel or equivalent advised)
  • 2 Gb RAM
  • 256Mb graphic card (512 MB highly recommended)
  • 260Mb Download size
  • 600Mb hard drive space